shutterstock_2724968243.jpg

Minor Informality Rule and Agency Discretion in Exercising Related Waiver Authority

In negotiated procurements, it is the responsibility of the offerors to submit timely and responsive proposals with current, accurate, and complete information that meet solicitation requirements and permit a meaningful evaluation. At the same time, because proposals in response to government contract solicitations are often voluminous, they may contain informalities and minor irregularities. The minor informality rule permits the procuring agency to waive such immaterial deviations from solicitation requirements. Because the rule is permissive rather than mandatory, it grants agencies discretion to waive the informalities. As one would expect, the scope of agency discretion in this area is considerable and it is generally within the government’s discretion to elect to exercise its waiver authority. However, as with other situations involving the government’s sound exercise of discretion, agency discretion under the minor informality rule is not unlimited. One limitation on the procuring agency’s authority is that the waiver decision should not undermine the validity of the award and prejudice other offerors. Under its bid protest function, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) can review agency decisions involving such waivers to determine whether they have a reasonable basis.

In B-423599, a decision issued on September 11, 2025, the GAO found that the procuring agency properly waived the awardee’s failure to sign Standard Form (SF) 33 as a minor informality. The Navy issued a request for proposals (RFP) for engineering, technical, and programmatic services to support command and control in naval operations and contemplated awarding the contract after a best value tradeoff between technical factors and cost. After finding the technical factors between the two proposals as essentially equal, the agency made the award based on evaluated cost. In the protest that followed, among other arguments, the protester maintained that the awardee was ineligible for award because it failed to sign its SF 33. The agency conceded this fact but argued instead that it properly waived the awardee’s unsigned SF 33 as a minor informality because the awardee had indicated a clear intent to be bound by its proposal. The GAO agreed, noting material indications in the awardee’s proposal of its intent to be bound. In this regard, the awardee’s proposal included a cover letter signed by an authorized individual confirming that it took no exceptions to the solicitation’s terms and committing to a 240-day offer validity period. Furthermore, aside from being unsigned, the SF 33 was otherwise complete and, crucially, identified the same individual who signed the awardee’s cover letter. Under these circumstances, the GAO held that it was entirely permissible for the agency to waive the unsigned SF 33 as only a minor informality.

Meanwhile, in B-419093, a decision issued on December 11, 2020, the GAO denied a protest alleging that the procuring agency should have waived the late submission of a proposed subcontractor’s portion of the proposal under the minor informality rule. The Naval Air Warfare Center Aircraft Division issued the relevant RFP for contractor-owned and operated air-to-air refueling services. The protester timely submitted its portion of the proposal via the Department of Defense (DOD) Secure Access File Exchange (SAFE) site. However, its proposed subcontractor submitted its portion of the proposal one hour after the stated deadline. Upon determining that the subcontractor’s portion of the proposal contained material information, the agency deemed the protester’s proposal late and eliminated it from competition. In the protest that followed, among other arguments, the protester contended that, notwithstanding its lateness, the subcontractor’s submission should have been considered by the agency under the minor informality rule. The GAO noted that the solicitation incorporated Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) 52.215-1(f)(3), which provides that “[t]he government may waive informalities and minor irregularities in proposals received.” Nevertheless, the protester’s argument was found unpersuasive because the minor informality rule is permissive rather than mandatory. In other words, the Navy had the discretion to waive any minor informalities but was not required to do so. Furthermore, the pertinent language of the FAR provision made it applicable only to proposals received by the procuring agency, and the subcontractor’s material submission was not timely received by the Navy. Accordingly, it was within the agency’s sound exercise of discretion not to exercise its waiver authority under the minor informality rule.

Although procuring agencies possess considerable latitude in evaluations, their waiver authority, including their discretion in electing not to waive minor informalities, is not unlimited. In B-292097, a decision issued on May 29, 2023, the GAO held that it was improper for the agency not to waive the late delivery of the paper version of the protester’s proposal as a minor informality when the agency received a timely and complete electronic copy per the solicitation instructions. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) issued the RFP for construction quality management services. As relevant here, offerors were required to submit both paper and electronic versions of their proposals. While the protester timely submitted an electronic version of its proposal, the paper version was late, and the agency rejected the proposal on this basis. In the protest before the GAO, the protester argued that because the agency received a complete and identical electronic copy of its proposal in a timely manner, its failure to submit a timely paper copy was a minor informality that should have been waived. Meanwhile, the agency pointed to the relevant regulatory language in FAR 52.215-1(f)(3) as being permissive and argued that it was entirely within the discretion of the contracting officer (CO) not to waive the untimeliness of the paper proposal. In sustaining the protest, the GAO reminded the agency that the CO’s discretion in electing whether to waive minor informalities was not unlimited and that she still needed a reasonable basis for her decision. Given the timely, identical, and complete electronic submission in this case, there was no possible reasonable basis for the CO to decline to waive the lateness of the protester’s paper proposal as an immaterial deviation from solicitation requirements.

Under the minor informality rule in applicable negotiated procurements, procuring agencies may waive informalities and minor irregularities in an offeror’s proposal. A limitation on the government’s waiver authority is that the validity of the award must not be undermined, and other offerors should not be prejudiced. As demonstrated in the protests described above, the GAO has addressed the soundness of the government’s exercise of discretion under the minor informality rule in various circumstances. In addition to cases involving failure to deliver a second copy of a proposal when an identical, complete copy was timely delivered to the government, the GAO has also recognized that minor informalities in System for Award Management (SAM) registrations do not undermine the validity of the award and are waivable by procuring agencies without prejudice to other offerors. This applies to an offeror’s errors in ensuring that its SAM registration is accurate and complete, including errors or omissions in identifying its immediate and highest-level owners. Contractors should be mindful that since the rule is permissive, it vests in the agencies the discretion to waive immaterial deviations in proposals from solicitation requirements, rather than mandating such a waiver. That said, as demonstrated above, procuring agencies do not have unlimited discretion in electing to waive informalities and minor irregularities. As with any exercise of government discretion, the decision to waive or decline to waive such informalities must have a reasonable basis.

This Federal Procurement Insight is provided as a general summary of the applicable law in the practice area and does not constitute legal advice. Contractors wishing to learn more are encouraged to consult the TILLIT LAW PLLC Client Portal or Contact Us to determine how the law would apply in a specific situation.

Related Insights

Shutterstock_267632282.jpg

Bid protest adjudicative forums such as the Government Accountability Office (GAO) have consistently held that a proposal that fails to meet a material solicitation requirement is considered technically unacceptable and cannot form the basis of an award. When included in the solicitation as mandatory, a prospective contractor’s adherence to the government’s small business participation requirements may be considered a material solicitation requirement. In such solicitations, an adequate response to a mandatory small business participation requirement not only addresses the requirement in the relevant proposal section but is also consistent across all sections of the offeror’s proposal, including its pricing. When an offeror fails to adequately respond to a solicitation’s mandatory small business participation requirement, its proposal contains a material defect. Such a proposal defect is typically only correctable when the government opens discussions, permitting offerors to submit revised proposals. Thus, if the procuring agency fails to open discussions to resolve the material proposal defect, it may not then properly award the contract to an offeror that failed to meet the solicitation’s mandatory requirements.

more
Shutterstock_1334090654-2.jpg

Past performance evaluations play an integral role in determining the capability of competing offerors to perform. Solicitations describe the government’s intended approach for evaluating past performance, and an offeror’s past performance is typically evaluated by reviewing performance histories on individual procurements. As long as the evaluations are consistent with the solicitation and all proposals are evaluated on an equal basis, it is within the procuring agency’s discretion to determine the scope of the offerors’ performance histories to be considered. There are situations where a contractor contests a recently assigned past performance rating by disputing the government’s interpretation of the facts relating to its performance. However, even when a past performance rating is being disputed, a procuring agency may base its evaluation upon a reasonable perception of inadequate past performance. The contractor’s efforts to dispute the past performance rating, or its continued disagreement with the agency that assigned the rating, may be disregarded by the procuring agency when conducting the past performance evaluation.

In B-423103, a bid protest decision issued on January 15, 2025, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) found the procuring agency’s past performance evaluation fair and reasonable despite the protester’s assertion that a past performance rating considered during the evaluation was a matter of an unresolved and ongoing dispute. The Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) issued a request for quotation (RFQ) to acquire 85 commercial piston seals for the Apache and Black Hawk helicopters. The piston seals were deemed critical application items, with the awardee and the protester designated as the only approved sources. The awardee’s quotation was evaluated as acceptable. Meanwhile, the contracting officer (CO) noted the protester’s recent performance under a contract for the same items as having quality issues, following issuance of a stop-work order for supplying non-conforming material. Based on this evaluation, the contract was awarded to the awardee, and the protester filed its protest.

more
Shutterstock_2265979599-3.jpg

Generally, when a government contract solicitation sets forth requirements in specific terms, interested offerors are required to meet them precisely. This is especially true for material requirements which must be satisfied in order for an offeror’s proposal to be considered technically acceptable for award. However, in certain limited circumstances the procuring agency may relax or waive material solicitation requirements in making an award, if the proposed solution meets the government’s needs and there is no prejudice to the other offerors. In such cases, it is insufficient for a protester seeking to challenge the government’s waiver of material solicitation requirements to merely show that it would have been next in line for award, or that the awardee would have been unsuccessful but for the waiver. Rather, the existence of competitive prejudice is established by demonstrating that the protester would have altered its proposal to its advantage or could have done something different to improve its chances for award had it been afforded the opportunity to submit a response to the changed solicitation requirements.

In B-423821.2; B-423821.3, a decision issued on April 20, 2026, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) denied a protest challenging the agency’s waiver of material solicitation requirements in making the award because the protester failed to demonstrate competitive prejudice. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) issued a $43,712,124 task order under an indefinite-delivery, indefinite-quantity (IDIQ) contract for operation, maintenance, and facility management services at various Defense Health Agency (DHA) facilities in Germany, Belgium, and Italy. For the portion of the work to be performed in Italy, the request for proposals (RFP) required offerors to register for an anti-mafia screening white list. During discussions, the USACE reiterated the white list requirement, explaining that offerors were required to initiate the registration process with a local government official known as a prefetto before submitting their proposals. Prospective offerors were advised that they had to include evidence of having initiated the registration process with their proposal submissions.

more
shutterstock_2381551119 copy.jpg

Proposals that fail to satisfy the material terms of a solicitation for a negotiated procurement are considered unacceptable and may not form the basis of an award. It is well-established that it is the offeror’s responsibility to submit an adequately written proposal in accordance with the solicitation’s terms that contains all the required information. Despite this obligation, offerors may inadvertently omit necessary information from their proposals. Similarly, proposals may inadequately address or otherwise fail to convey information required by the solicitation. In such cases, the offeror risks adverse evaluation by the procuring agency or elimination from the competition altogether. Protests challenging the agency’s adverse decisions in such cases can have a low success rate because the Government Accountability Office (GAO) does not reevaluate proposals or substitute its judgment for that of the agency but only ensures the reasonableness of the evaluation against the stated evaluation criteria and applicable procurement laws and regulations. Contractors should also be mindful that their disagreement with the agency’s judgment alone is insufficient to establish the unreasonableness of the evaluation. Furthermore, while the agency may elect to seek clarifications, when a solicitation contemplates award without discussions, providing an opportunity for offerors to resolve even minor or clerical errors in their proposals is firmly within the agency’s discretion, as there is no automatic right to clarifications.

more

Minor Informality Rule and Agency Discretion in Exercising Related Waiver Authority

TILLIT LAW Federal Procurement Insights