Featured Insights
As outside counsel, the firm's role is often more than providing zealous representation and dependable counsel to our clients. The firm views its relationship with its clients as an ongoing partnership in their success. The firm consistently provides its clients and prospective clients with impactful insights on public procurement topics and developments relevant to their industry in a timely fashion.
TILLIT LAW PLLC's government contracts law and regulations resources offer helpful insights and practical perspectives, enabling clients to successfully navigate the constantly evolving regulatory environment that impacts them. TILLIT LAW's exclusive selection of internally developed content is directly influenced by what the firm's past, current, and prospective clients find helpful.
Whether you are a seasoned government contractor or a newcomer to the industry, TILLIT LAW encourages all its clients to use the "Featured Insights" section of this site regularly to stay informed about stories, trends, and developments most impacting their businesses. The firm's Featured Insights Articles are categorized so clients and prospective clients may stay informed about the latest developments in federal procurement law and easily find relevant information about topics of present interest.
Some of the most recent Featured Insights articles can be found on this page. The firm's entire featured insights repository can be accessed on GovConFeaturedInsights.com powered by LexBlog™. This fully searchable platform features over 150 informative articles and posts on federal contracts law topics, spanning the entire procurement lifecycle.
Recent Featured Insights
Minor Informality Rule and Agency Discretion in Exercising Related Waiver Authority
Sareesh Rawat, Esq.
In negotiated procurements, it is the responsibility of the offerors to submit timely and responsive proposals with current, accurate, and complete information that meet solicitation requirements and permit a meaningful evaluation. At the same time, because proposals in response to government contract solicitations are often voluminous, they may contain informalities and minor irregularities. The minor informality rule permits the procuring agency to waive such immaterial deviations from solicitation requirements. Because the rule is permissive rather than mandatory, it grants agencies discretion to waive the informalities. As one would expect, the scope of agency discretion in this area is considerable and it is generally within the government’s discretion to elect to exercise its waiver authority. However, as with other situations involving the government’s sound exercise of discretion, agency discretion under the minor informality rule is not unlimited. One limitation on the procuring agency’s authority is that the waiver decision should not undermine the validity of the award and prejudice other offerors. Under its bid protest function, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) can review agency decisions involving such waivers to determine whether they have a reasonable basis.
moreClaims Involving Warranty of Utilities
Sareesh Rawat, Esq.
Performance of contracts on government sites often require contractor’s access to utilities such electricity, water, gas etc. In such contracts, the government may provide a warranty regarding the availability of utilities. The inclusion in the contract of the “Availability and Use of Utility Services” standard clause at FAR 52.236-14 as prescribed in FAR 36.514 is interpreted as a government warranty of utilities. Fixed-price construction contracts typically contain this standard clause when performance is contemplated on government sites, the available utilities are adequate for the needs of both the government and the contractor, and it is in the government’s interest to furnish the utilities. Unless the contract states otherwise, the standard clause makes it the contractor’s responsibility to pay utility charges at the prevailing rates charged to the government. When the utilities are produced by the government, the contractor is responsible for utility payments based on reasonable rates determined by the contracting officer (CO). In contracts without the standard clause, claims adjudicative forums review the relevant contractual language to determine whether the government has warranted the availability of utilities. Both the standard clause and relevant contract language are strictly interpreted in accordance with their plain meaning to determine if a warranty of utilities exists and whether the contractor is responsible for the payment of any utility charges.
moreProtests Challenging Key Personnel Experience Requirements
Sareesh Rawat, Esq.
Key personnel proposed to perform a government contract are of critical importance and can often be the difference between a successful and an unsuccessful proposal. Procuring agencies’ discretion in determining their minimum needs and the best method for accommodating them extends to deciding whether key personnel are required and, if so, what level of experience and qualifications they must possess. Offerors who cannot meet the solicitation’s key personnel experience requirements, or who view them as unfavorable, may challenge the requirements for being unduly restrictive. Such protests are generally based on alleged improprieties apparent on the face of the solicitation and must be filed with the Government Accountability Office (GAO) before the closing time for receipt of initial proposals. Under a limited exception to this rule, when a protester has filed an agency-level protest, a subsequent GAO protest on the same issue must be filed within 10 days of an adverse government action on the agency-level protest. Once a solicitation’s key personnel experience requirements are timely challenged, the agency must establish that the requirements are reasonably necessary to meet its needs. The agency’s justification for the key personnel experience requirements must be rational and able to withstand logical scrutiny. However, the agency need not document its consideration of less restrictive approaches or neutralize the competitive landscape and advantages of any incumbent contractors. Furthermore, the fact that the requirements may prevent certain firms from obtaining positive ratings is not dispositive of whether they are unduly restrictive.
moreConsiderations Involving Key Personnel Qualifications Information
Sareesh Rawat, Esq.
When evaluating key personnel qualifications, agencies generally assess the experience of the personnel proposed by the contractor against the requirements of the solicitation. Depending on the evaluation criteria, a proposal may be subject to downgraded ratings and even elimination if it fails to provide the necessary information demonstrating that the proposed key personnel possess the type and level of experience and qualifications required by the solicitation. Therefore, it is crucial that offerors include current, accurate, and responsive experience information in key personnel resumes and other relevant sections of their proposals. The evaluation of proposed key personnel qualifications is based on all information provided to the agency, sometimes including information not specifically stated in key personnel resumes. For instance, the government must consider any key personnel qualifications information received from the offeror during discussions. On the other hand, agencies are not required to consider information that an offeror fails to provide, even if evaluators have personal knowledge of the information through other sources. In this respect, the evaluation of key personnel qualifications differs from that of past performance information due to the inapplicability of the “too close at hand” principle, under which evaluators are required to consider certain past performance information personally known to them even if that information is not provided by the offeror in response to the solicitation.
moreSubscribe to Updates & Insights
TILLIT LAW PLLC newsletter delivered straight to your inbox.




